to the ninth article of the said allegations she said and deposed that since the articulate Wm Collins coming to dwell in Haulsted articulate this deponent dwelt with him as his household servant a year and five weeks within these three years last past during which time she saith that the articulate Wm Collin used the articulate Isabel Collin his wife very kindly and lovingly but she the said Isabel was unkind and undutiful to him both in his diet and in her other behaviour towards him and further she does not know to depose saving what deposed below